Whether you’re a local craving a slice or a visitor looking for the best bite in town, Birmingham offers an incredible array of pizza options for every taste. From classic Italian-style pizzas to innovative toppings and crusts, this list introduces you to some of the city’s finest pizza places. Here are the 8 best pizza spots in Birmingham that will satisfy your cravings, whether you’re searching for a pizza shop near me or simply the best pizza experience.
1. Rudy’s Neapolitan Pizza
If you’re a fan of authentic Neapolitan pizza, Rudy’s Neapolitan Pizza is a must-visit. Nestled in the heart of Birmingham, Rudy’s has a cozy yet lively atmosphere where you can enjoy the classic Italian tradition of pizza. They use San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and a soft, chewy crust that’s perfectly blistered from the wood-fired oven. Popular options include the classic Margherita and their signature “Calabrese” with spicy nduja sausage. Their location in the city center makes it a convenient stop for anyone looking for a truly Italian pizza experience.
2. Otto Pizza
Otto Pizza brings a twist to traditional pizza by combining artisanal craftsmanship with unique, mouth-watering toppings. Known for its innovative approach, Otto sources local ingredients and creates seasonal pizzas with options you won’t find anywhere else. Try their “Truffle Shuffle” for a rich, earthy flavour or the “Smoky Joe” topped with smoked meats for a savory delight. Otto is a perfect choice for those looking to try something new and unforgettable in pizza places in Birmingham.
3. Fumo
Fumo offers more than just pizza; it’s a complete Italian dining experience with modern interiors and an extensive menu of Italian specialities. The pizzas at Fumo are crafted with care, featuring a thin crust and toppings such as wild mushrooms, fresh basil, and prosciutto. The “Pesto Chicken” pizza is a local favourite, combining tender chicken pieces with creamy pesto. Located on Waterloo Street, Fumo is an upscale choice for those wanting a sophisticated pizza outing.
4. The Plough
For a relaxed, neighbourhood vibe, The Plough in Harborne is a fantastic spot. Known for its rustic decor and welcoming atmosphere, The Plough serves up wood-fired pizzas that are as delicious as they are satisfying. The “Garden Veg” pizza is a hit, loaded with seasonal vegetables and sprinkled with fresh herbs, while their “Pepperoni Special” is a classic choice with a bit of a kick. This local favourite brings a warm, communal feel to the pizza scene in Birmingham, perfect for both casual nights out and group gatherings.
5. Laghi’s Deli
A blend of deli and pizzeria, Laghi’s Deli captures the essence of Italy in every slice. Located in Edgbaston, this family-owned spot is known for its quality and authenticity. Their pizzas feature a light, airy crust that pairs well with premium toppings such as truffle oil, rocket, and Parmesan. Their “Prosciutto e Funghi” pizza is highly recommended, combining flavours that are both rich and comforting. Laghi’s Deli also offers a range of Italian dishes, so you can make it a full Italian feast if you wish!
6. Peacer
For those who appreciate New York-style pizza, Peacer in Moseley delivers massive, foldable slices that are all about flavour and indulgence. Their minimalist approach to toppings emphasizes quality over quantity, making each ingredient shine. The “Hot Honey” pizza, topped with spicy salami and a drizzle of honey, offers a perfect balance of sweet and spicy. This is a cozy, hip spot with a great ambiance, ideal for catching up with friends or enjoying a casual pizza night out.
7. Franco Manca
A nationwide favourite, Franco Manca in Birmingham brings high-quality, sourdough pizza to the heart of the city. Their unique, slow-fermented dough offers a distinct tangy flavour and airy texture that sets their pizzas apart. Franco Manca is also well-known for its sustainably sourced ingredients and seasonal menu items. For something classic yet flavorful, try their “Tomato, Mozzarella, and Basil” pizza, or opt for a more adventurous choice with the “Chorizo & Ricotta.” If you’re ever searching for a pizza shop near me in Birmingham, Franco Manca is a dependable option that never disappoints.
8. Original Patty Men (OPM)
While best known for its burgers, Original Patty Men surprises patrons with its outstanding pizza. Located in Digbeth, OPM has earned a reputation for delivering bold, flavour-packed dishes that push culinary boundaries. The “Cheeseburger Pizza” is a standout, blending flavours from both worlds to create a one-of-a-kind taste experience. Perfect for anyone who loves fusion cuisine, OPM is a hidden gem in Birmingham’s pizza scene that’s worth the visit.
Why These Pizza Spots Stand Out
Each of these pizza places in Birmingham has something unique to offer, from the flavours of authentic Italy to modern culinary twists. Here’s a closer look at why these spots make the list of Birmingham’s best:
- Authenticity: Rudy’s and Laghi’s Deli bring genuine Italian flavours to their pizzas with traditional ingredients and methods.
- Innovative Toppings: Places like Otto and Original Patty Men offer a departure from classic pizza, introducing inventive toppings that appeal to modern tastes.
- Ambiance: The Plough and Fumo provide the perfect settings for both casual hangouts and fine dining experiences, ensuring there’s a place for every mood and occasion.
- Sustainability and Local Sourcing: Franco Manca’s commitment to sustainability and Peacer’s support for local farmers highlight their dedication to quality and responsibility in every bite.
Finding Your Next Slice with Compare Eats
When you’re craving pizza in Birmingham, let Compare Eats guide you to the best spots in town. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavours, unique topping combinations, or artisanal, handcrafted pies, these 8 pizza places promise an unforgettable experience. Each location provides an excellent taste of Birmingham’s diverse culinary scene, blending tradition with innovation. So, if you’re ready to explore, start with these top picks and discover your new favourite pizza place in Birmingham.
